No, minister: Gov't must take responsibility for the DB debacle

Loading player...
A breakdown of communication; failure to learn the lessons of the past; policy problems; improper planning; regulatory stalemate; and, of course, denial.

A perfect storm involving all these factors and more led to what Personal Finance Society CEO Keith Richards now candidly calls a 'DB debacle'.

In this episode, James Fitzgerald sits down with Richards to hear his side of the story.

It is an honest look at how the defined benefit (DB) pension transfer scandal unfolded, from the perspective of a key industry stakeholder trying to unite an overlooked and occasionally divided profession in the face of huge regulatory and business pressures.

Notably, Richards also reflects on the FCA and Treasury's 'failed' Financial Advice Market Review, and describes how Brexit arrived at precisely the wrong moment for a multi-pronged taskforce consisting of industry representatives, lobbyists, consumer protection experts, ministers and civil servants to make any meaningful progress.

Will lobbyists like Richard make any ground? It is entirely possible, Richards argues, but the government must come back to the table first. Consider that gauntlet thoroughly thrown down.
29 Jan 2021 English United Kingdom Business · Investing

Other recent episodes

FCA director: We want consolidators to think about incentives

Laura Dawes, the FCA’s director of authorisations, joins the Advice Show to discuss how the regulator is handling authorisations, what advice firms can do to make applications smooth and how the regulator still thinks about advice firm phoenixing. Dawes also discusses the regulator’s consolidator review last year, and how the…
26 Feb 23 min

Connor Broadley’s MD on picking the right tech for the £750m firm

Alex Twiss, the managing director of London advice firm Connor Broadley, joins the Advice Show to discuss the firm’s AI provider Saturn and how he thinks the technology could soon be writing advisers’ suitability reports. In the podcast Twiss also says his firm is reviewing platform providers and discusses the…
6 Feb 33 min

The Advice Show: Matthew Sinclair 

Matthew Sinclair joins the week after the Budget to discuss its impact, implications and what the government might have done differently.
9 Dec 2025 28 min

The Advice Show: Ben Hampton

Ben Hampton joins The Advice Show this week to discuss Wealth Wizards, the business he heads, as well as targeted support, value for money and Royal London. 
16 Jan 28 min